
The colour cards are spread across the kitchen bench. Charcoal, a slightly different charcoal, a grey that looked lovely in the shop, and a red that matches the original tiles. The roof is booked in for a paint and somebody has to pick one. Choosing roof painting colours sounds like the easy part of the job. In our experience it's the part owners agonise over longest, and it's the one they look at every day for years afterwards.
Here's how we'd go about it on a home in Melbourne's north. Start with the things that rule colours out. Taste gets its vote after that.
Check the rules before you fall for a colour
Two kinds of rules can limit what goes on your roof, and both are worth sorting before the quote rather than after the first coat.
The first is a heritage overlay. Plenty of homes in Brunswick, Northcote, Thornbury and parts of Ivanhoe sit under one. Where an overlay applies, changing the colour or finish of a roof that can be seen from the street may need council approval. A natural terracotta roof on an Edwardian house painted a bold modern shade is exactly the kind of change that draws attention. Your council's planning department can tell you whether an overlay covers your property and what it asks for.
The second turns up on the newer estates around Craigieburn, Mill Park, South Morang and Epping. Many of those blocks were sold with design guidelines or a covenant on the title that sets out acceptable roof colours, usually a palette of greys and muted tones. Some of these lapse after a period and some don't. Your title documents, or the conveyancer who handled the purchase, will have the answer.
Dark roofs look sharp, light roofs run cooler
Colour changes how much heat the roof soaks up. A light coating reflects more of the sun and a dark one absorbs more, so on a hot January afternoon a charcoal roof gets noticeably hotter than a pale grey one.
How much of that reaches the rooms below depends on what's under the tiles. A home with decent ceiling insulation and sarking (the foil layer laid under tiles or sheets) feels the difference far less than an old bungalow with very little in the roof space. Many coating ranges now include heat reflective versions, often sold as cool roof paint, which are designed to throw back more heat than a standard coating of the same shade. Worth asking about if you love a dark colour but the back bedroom already cooks every summer.
Dark colours have a practical case too. They hide dust and the odd tree stain between cleans, and they suit the dark gutters and window frames on a lot of newer homes. Lighter roofs can show dirt and lichen streaks sooner, especially on the shaded south faces where moss gets going on so many roofs around Coburg and Preston.
Let the bricks write your shortlist
Most houses already have a big fixed colour that isn't changing any time soon: the walls. That's the best place to start. Across the north, the pairings we see work best tend to follow the house type.
- Red brick interwar bungalows in Preston, Coburg and Reservoir: the original terracotta red is the safe, period-true choice. Charcoal and deep greys sit well against red brick too.
- Cream and blonde brick from the 1960s and 70s around Bundoora, Watsonia and Greensborough: warmer greys, browns and charcoal. Bright reds tend to fight with cream brick.
- Rendered and newer estate homes in Craigieburn and Mill Park: whatever the estate palette allows, mostly mid to dark greys such as Monument, Basalt and Woodland Grey.
- Weatherboards in Northcote and Thornbury: pick up the trim colour, within any heritage guidance.
Then look at the gutters, fascia and downpipes. If they're Colorbond and staying put, the roof either matches them or contrasts on purpose. Many roof coating ranges include shades made to match the Colorbond palette, which makes this much easier. If the gutters are being replaced at the same time, you've got a free hand.
A colour chip will lie to you
This one surprises people. A small swatch held up under the kitchen light tells you very little about how a whole roof will look. Across a large area in full sun, most colours read lighter than the chip, and the pitch of the roof changes how much light it throws back. A grey that looked mid-tone on the card can look close to silver from the street. Charcoal can read almost black on an overcast day.
A few ways to get a truer picture:
- Find a roof in your street, or the next few, already painted the colour you're considering.
- Look at it in morning light and again late in the afternoon.
- Ask for a painted sample tile and sit it outside in the sun for a day or two.
- Judge it from across the street, not from your driveway. That's how everyone else sees it.
Original terracotta doesn't have to be painted at all
The terracotta tiles on a lot of interwar homes already have the colour people often try to recreate with paint. If those tiles are sound, cleaning and sealing them instead keeps the natural finish. A clear sealer protects the face of the tile without changing its look, and our guide to sealing roof tiles explains what that does and doesn't achieve.
Terracotta can be painted with the right primer. Just go in knowing it's a one way street: once it's painted, getting back to the bare clay look isn't really an option. Concrete tiles are different. Once their original colour has worn away to grey, painting is the only way to bring colour back, so the question there is which colour, not whether.
Preparation decides how long the colour lasts
Whatever shade you choose, how well it holds up depends far more on the work underneath than on the colour. The roof needs a thorough clean, any broken tiles and loose pointing fixed, the right primer for tile or metal, then the topcoats. Skip the prep and even the best colour will peel and go patchy. The north and west facing sides of any roof always weather fastest, whatever the shade.
Colour itself rarely moves the price much, although a big jump from a dark roof to a light one can need extra coverage. If you're weighing up budget as well, our breakdown of what a roof paint job costs in Melbourne's north covers how quotes are put together. And if you want to see how we handle the clean, repairs and coating on tile and metal roofs, our roof painting service page walks through it. Our roof restorations come with a 10-year written guarantee on workmanship and materials (conditions apply).
"We recently had Ian restore and paint our metal roof and gutters. He did an amazing job. Nothing was too much trouble. Ian was efficient and professional. We were so impressed that we recommended him to do our daughters' tile roof as well. They were also very happy with their experience. Charlie & Gillian"
Bring your shortlist to the quote
By the time you've checked the rules, looked at the bricks and seen a few real roofs in your street, most people are down to two or three colours. That's a good point to get someone up on the roof. It's also when you find out whether the roof needs repairs before any paint goes on, because no colour fixes cracked tiles or fretting ridge mortar.
We inspect and quote free across Melbourne's northern suburbs, from Brunswick and Preston out to Eltham and Craigieburn. Call (03) 9498 1000, or book a free roof painting inspection and quote and bring your colour cards along.
