
The quote for your new metal roof has two options on it. One says Zincalume, the other says Colorbond, and the Zincalume one is a bit cheaper. So the obvious question follows: what am I actually giving up? Zincalume vs Colorbond is one of the things we get asked most when we price a metal re-roof in Melbourne's north. The honest answer is less than most people expect. But not nothing.
Here's what really separates the two, where each one makes sense on the kinds of homes we work on, and the couple of situations where the choice gets made for you.
Colorbond is Zincalume with paint baked on
This is the part that surprises people. Both start life as the same steel sheet with the same metallic coating, a blend of aluminium and zinc that protects the steel from rust. Zincalume is that sheet left bare, which gives it a bright silver finish. Colorbond takes the same sheet and adds a factory primer and a baked-on paint layer in one of a range of standard colours.
So the strength of the sheet and its core rust protection come from the same place. The sheet shapes are the same too, from classic corrugated through to the flatter modern profiles. Hail treats them the same as well: it dents steel rather than cracking through it, which is why metal roofs suit the hail-prone corridor around Craigieburn and Mill Park whichever finish you pick.
What the paint changes is how the roof looks, how hot it runs, how it handles scratches and what your council and neighbours may think about it. Those are the things worth weighing.
The price gap is smaller than the sheet price suggests
Zincalume sheets usually cost a little less than the same profile in Colorbond, because there's no paint system on them. Supplier pricing moves around, so we won't promise a set gap, but bare metal is normally the cheaper line on the quote.
Keep in mind that the sheets are only one part of a re-roof. Stripping the old roof, new sarking (the protective layer laid under the sheets), battens, ridges, valleys, flashings and the labour to put it all together cost the same whichever finish goes on top. So the saving shrinks once you look at the whole job. If you want to see where the rest of the money goes, our guide to what drives the price of a full re-roof breaks it down. On a replacement, we'd rarely tell anyone to pick the finish on price alone.
How each one looks a few years in
New Zincalume is bright. Over its first years it weathers from a shiny silver to a softer, duller grey, and it doesn't always do that evenly. Some owners like that plain, working look, and on a farmhouse or an older home it can look exactly right. Others find it a bit shed-like on a suburban house.
Colorbond holds its colour much longer, though it does slowly fade and chalk under the sun, more so on north and west facing pitches. You can also match it to your gutters, fascia and fences. On the newer estates around Craigieburn, Mill Park and Epping, greys like Monument, Basalt and Woodland Grey are the usual look, and a bare silver roof can stand out from the rest of the street.
Heat, glare and the people next door
Bare Zincalume reflects a lot of sunlight when it's new. That helps keep heat off the roof, but it can also throw glare into a neighbour's windows, especially from a low-pitched roof or where a two-storey home sits beside single-storey ones. Some councils and estate design rules limit highly reflective roofing for exactly that reason, so check before you set your heart on it. As the metal dulls, the glare fades, and so does some of that reflectivity.
Colorbond is made with Thermatech solar reflectance technology, which helps cut the heat load on the roof. The colour you choose matters a lot here. A light shade such as Surfmist will keep the roof space cooler on a hot day than a dark one like Monument. Either way, the bigger difference to how your house feels in January comes from the sarking and insulation under the sheets, and we spec insulation as part of every metal roof quote.
Copper, lead and scratches: the shared weak spots
Because they share the same base coating, both finishes share the same enemies. Water running off copper pipes or old lead flashings speeds up corrosion on either one. When we plan a new metal roof we look for copper air conditioner lines, old hot water units and leftover lead flashings that drain onto the sheets. Wet leaf litter left sitting in valleys and gutters does the same slow damage to both.
Scratches are where they part ways. A light scuff on Zincalume tends to weather in and disappear. On Colorbond, a scratch through the paint shows, and dabbing touch-up paint on it often looks worse a year or two later, because the new paint weathers to a different shade. That's one reason careful handling on the roof matters more with Colorbond.
On a period home, the old roof may decide it
Many of the Victorian and Edwardian homes in Brunswick and Northcote were first roofed in galvanised corrugated iron, which is steel coated in zinc alone. Where a heritage overlay applies, there can be limits on changing a roof's material or colour, and a bare metal finish is often closer to what was there originally. That doesn't rule Colorbond out, but it isn't always your call alone. We check what applies to the property before we quote, so you're not choosing between two finishes when only one is allowed.
Already have Zincalume? It can be painted
Plenty of homes around Reservoir and Coburg have older Zincalume roofs where the metal is still in good condition. If you'd like colour but the roof doesn't need replacing, it can be cleaned, have any rust treated, be primed with a metal primer and finished in a professional-grade elastomeric coating. Often a full restoration like that extends the life of a sound roof by 10 to 15 years at a fraction of replacement cost.
The trade-off is that it's a coating applied on site rather than a factory paint system, so it will want attention again down the track. And if the sheets are rusting through rather than just looking tired, paint isn't the answer. The warning signs are much the same as the ones in our guide to how long a metal roof really lasts.
Our short answer for most homes in the north
For a suburban house, and anywhere the roof is on show from the street, we'd usually point you to Colorbond. It's the most popular choice for the replacements and tile to metal conversions we do. You get a colour that suits the house, less glare for the neighbours and a finish that stays tidy for years.
Zincalume earns its place when the budget is genuinely tight, on sheds and carports, on rural and semi-rural blocks out towards Whittlesea and Kangaroo Ground, and on period homes where the original look matters. It isn't the lesser product. It's the same steel without the paint.
Whichever you choose, the install is the same on our jobs: the old roof fully stripped, new sarking and treated pine battens, and every ridge, hip, valley and flashing sealed. We supply and fit both finishes as part of our new metal roofs and metal re-roofs, and our replacements carry a 10-year written guarantee on workmanship and materials (conditions apply).
If you're weighing up the two for your own place, we can come out, look at the house and the street, check for any overlay and price both finishes on the same quote. Inspections and quotes are free. Call (03) 9498 1000, or see what's involved in a Colorbond or Zincalume roof first.
